Scottish Water fined £7,500 for pollution of the Caaf Water and River Garnock

date05 August 2016

Scottish Water was fined £7,500 at Kilmarnock Sheriff Court yesterday (4 August 2016) for causing the pollution of the Caaf Water and River Garnock in Dalry, Ayrshire.

Problem with ShowGallery

Scottish Water pled guilty to causing or permitting other persons to draw down the level of water in the Caaf Reservoir through an inadequately monitored open valve. This resulted in the discharge of sediment laden water, containing a high level of suspended solids from the reservoir, into the Caaf Water and the River Garnock on 24 May 2015.

The Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) attended the site to carry out an investigation after receiving a number of complaints from members of the public about the discolouration of the Caaf Water at its confluence with the River Garnock. SEPA contacted Scottish Water to close the valve draining the reservoir in order to stop any further polluting discharge, and reported the matter to the Procurator Fiscal.

John McCabe, SEPA’s Reporting Officer, said:

The Caaf Water and River Garnock are very popular with countryside enthusiasts including anglers. As a result of this incident water heavily contaminated with sediment from the Caaf reservoir was introduced into these downstream watercourses at a concentration well beyond what would occur naturally, and this pollution remained visible for several days.

 “If Scottish Water had been monitoring the reservoir out of hours when the incident occurred, then it is likely the pollution to these rivers could have been prevented. Unfortunately as Scottish Water had not taken this precaution, we were informed by the public and had to request the valve draining the reservoir to be closed after these watercourses had already been polluted.”

In imposing the fine the court took into account the fact that this was a serious failure which resulted in detriment to the wildlife, which was striking, but the long term impact was unknown.

Ends

Notes to editors

The exact charge Scottish Water pled guilty to was:

On 24th May 2015 at Caaf Reservoir, Dalry, Ayrshire you did cause or permit other persons to contravene regulation 4 in that you did cause or permit other persons to carry on a controlled activity, namely an activity liable to cause pollution of the water environment in that you did cause or permit a) the draw down of the level of water in the Caaf Reservoir through an inadequately monitored open valve, and b) did cause or permit the discharge of sediment laden water containing a high level of suspended solids from said reservoir into the water environment namely the Caaf water and the River Garnock and did cause pollution otherwise than in accordance with an authorisation under the aftermentioned Regulations; CONTRARY to the Water Environment (Controlled Activities) (Scotland) Regulations 2011 Regulation 4 and 44(1)(a) and (o) and the Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Act 2003 Section 20(3)(a)